South Dade News Leader: Walter E Williams

Welcome!
|
Not you?||
Logout|My Account

Walter E Williams

Friday 07/21/2017
Slavery

Too many people believe that slavery is a "peculiar institution." That's what Kenneth Stampp called slavery in his book, "Peculiar Institution: Slavery in the Ante-Bellum South." But slavery is by no means peculiar, odd or unusual. It was common among ancient peoples such as the Egyptians, Babylonians, Assyrians, Hittites, Greeks, Persians, Armenians and many others. Large numbers of Christians were enslaved during the Ottoman wars in Europe. White slaves were common in Europe from the Dark Ages to the Middle Ages. It was only after A.D. 1600 that Europeans joined with Arabs and Africans and started the Atlantic slave trade. As David P. Forsythe wrote in his book, "The Globalist," "The fact remained that at the beginning of the nineteenth century an estimated three-quarters of all people alive were trapped in bondage against their will either in some form of slavery or serfdom."

While slavery constitutes one of the grossest encroachments on human liberty, it is by no means unique or restricted to the Western world or United States, as many liberal academics would have us believe. Much of their indoctrination of our young people, at all levels of education, paints our nation's founders as racist adherents to slavery, but the story is not so

simple.

At the time of the 1787 Constitutional Convention, slaves were about 40 percent of the population of the Southern colonies. Apportionment in the House of Representatives and the number of electoral votes each state would have in presidential elections would be based upon population. Southern delegates to the convention wanted slaves to be counted as one person. Northern delegates to the convention, and those opposed to slavery, wanted only free persons of each state to be counted for the purposes of apportionment in the House of Representatives and the Electoral College. The compromise reached was that each slave would be counted as only three-fifths of a person.

Many criticize this compromise as proof of racism. My question to these grossly uninformed critics is whether they would have found it more preferable for slaves to be counted as whole persons. Slaves counted as whole persons would have given slaveholding Southern states much more political power. Or, would the critics of the founders prefer that the Northern delegates not compromise and not allow slaves to be counted at all. If they did, it is likely that the Constitution would have not been

ratified. Thus, the question emerges is whether blacks would be better off with Northern states having gone their way and Southern states having gone theirs, resulting in no U.S. Constitution and no Union? Unlike today's pseudointellectuals, black abolitionist Frederick Douglass understood the compromise, saying that the three-fifths clause was "a downright disability laid upon the slaveholding states" that deprived them of "two-fifths of their natural basis of representation."

Douglass' vision was shared by Patrick Henry and others. Henry said, expressing the reality of the three-fifths compromise, "As much as I deplore slavery, I see that prudence forbids its abolition." With this union, Congress at least had the power to abolish slave trade by 1808. According to delegate James Wilson, many believed the anti-slave-trade clause laid "the foundation for banishing slavery out of this country." Many of the founders abhorred slavery. Their statements can be read on my website, walterewilliams.com.

The most unique aspect of slavery in the Western world was the moral outrage against it, which began to emerge in the 18th century and led to massive elimination efforts. It was Britain's military sea power that put an end to the slave trade. And our country fought a costly war that brought an end to slavery. Unfortunately, these facts about slavery are not in the lessons taught in our schools and colleges. Instead, there is gross misrepresentation and suggestion that slavery was a uniquely American practice.

Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason University.

Posted in Homestead, Opinion, Walter e williams on Friday, July 21, 2017 1:36 pm. Comments (0)


WALTER E. WILLIAMS

Walter E. Williams is a professor of economics at George Mason University. He is also the author of several books, which include The State Against Blacks and America: A Minority Viewpoint.

Friday 07/21/2017

Slavery

Friday 07/14/2017

Minimum Wage Cruelty

Saturday 07/08/2017

Colleges: Islands of Intolerance

Friday 06/30/2017

Were Confederate Generals Traitors?

Friday 06/16/2017

Rewriting American History

Sunday 05/21/2017

Sheer Lunacy on Campus

Friday 05/12/2017

What Do Leftists Celebrate?

Friday 04/07/2017

Is Profiling OK?

Friday 03/31/2017

A Minority View - Educational Sabotage

Friday 03/17/2017

Liberty is Not for Wimps

Friday 03/10/2017

College Campus Disgrace

Friday 02/17/2017

Pawns of Liberal

Friday 01/20/2017

International Trade Thuggery

Friday 07/08/2016

Thinking Beyond Stage One

Monday 04/18/2016

Attacking Our Nation's Founders

Tuesday 03/15/2016

The Seen and Unseen

Monday 02/29/2016

Gullible Americans

Tuesday 02/23/2016

Clinton and Sanders and Progressivism

Friday 01/01/2016

Misleading and Using Blacks

Friday 11/13/2015

Attacking Our Founders

Saturday 08/08/2015

Legal and Academic Equality Nonsense

Sunday 08/02/2015

Cure For Racial Dishonesty

Saturday 07/25/2015

Historical Ignorance II

Saturday 07/18/2015

Historical Ignorance

Saturday 07/11/2015

Fiddling Away The Future

Saturday 07/04/2015

Constitutional Ignorance And Dereliction

Saturday 06/27/2015

You're What You Say You Are

Saturday 06/20/2015

Culture And Social Pathology

Saturday 06/13/2015

Improving Black Education

Saturday 06/06/2015

Intellectual Dishonesty

Saturday 05/30/2015

Liberals Respect Me

Saturday 05/23/2015

The True Black Tragedy

Monday 05/18/2015

Some Odds And Ends

Friday 05/08/2015

Black Lives Matter

Tuesday 05/05/2015

California's Water Problem

Friday 04/24/2015

Some Thoughts And Questions

Friday 04/17/2015

Reality May Be Optional

Friday 04/10/2015

The Ticket To Prosperity

Friday 04/03/2015

Self-Enforcing Discrimination

Friday 03/27/2015

What's Gone Wrong With Democracy?

Friday 03/20/2015

Selma & Voting Rights Triumph

Friday 03/13/2015

Global Warming

Friday 03/06/2015

College Campus Update

Friday 02/27/2015

The Cancer Of Multiculturalism

Friday 02/20/2015

Shame

Friday 02/13/2015

Fairness And Justice

Monday 02/02/2015

Defense Against Demagogues

Thursday 01/22/2015

Will The West Defend Itself?

Thursday 01/15/2015

Basic Economics

Friday 01/09/2015

Liberal’s Use Of Black People, Part II